New York racing has a rich history filled with legendary figures and unforgettable moments. Among them, Oscar Barrera stands out as a trainer whose impact on the sport was nothing short of phenomenal. For those who witnessed the “Oscar days,” it was an experience that transcended mere horse racing; it was a spectacle that words can scarcely capture. While the grandeur of The Belmont Stakes and iconic rivalries like Affirmed and Alydar are etched in racing lore, the unique phenomenon surrounding Oscar Barrera’s claimed horses offers a fascinating glimpse into a distinct era of New York racing.
The story of Oscar Barrera’s remarkable success with claimed horses began subtly. It started with a tip from a friend, Jay, who owned a local gas station and was known for his generosity towards the author during leaner times. On a bleak, rain-soaked day at Aqueduct, Jay’s excitement was palpable. He revealed a unique betting angle: every horse Oscar Barrera claimed seemed to win. This was not a frequent occurrence, as Barrera only claimed a few horses per year, but the win rate was astonishing. Intrigued, the author placed a bet on Alturas, a horse Barrera had claimed, which was running at 10-1 odds. Despite initial hesitation and a modest initial bet, a gut feeling prompted a larger wager, ultimately turning $140 into approximately $1100. This initial success was the harbinger of a racing phenomenon that would soon captivate the New York racing scene.
The “Oscar claim” angle soon presented itself again with Dancer’s Melody. This horse, claimed for $7,500 – the lowest claiming level in New York – was set to race against allowance horses, a seemingly insurmountable challenge given his lack of speed. Yet, the prediction held true. Dancer’s Melody, despite his reputation as a plodder, surged to an unexpected early lead and won decisively, setting a track record for six furlongs that meet. This victory solidified the emerging pattern and signaled that the lucrative prices associated with Barrera’s claimed horses were likely to disappear as word spread.
As Oscar Barrera began claiming horses with greater frequency, moving from a few per year to several per month, his uncanny ability to win with them remained consistent. While trainer statistics for horses off claims were not readily available in racing forms back then, the success rate was undeniable. Factors like quick turnarounds (running back in three or four days), intense workouts, and equipment changes like blinkers often contributed to these victories. Though the element of surprise and the generous odds faded, replaced by opening lines of 6-5, betting on an Oscar Barrera horse became a near certainty. Regardless of the race’s appearance or the competition, these horses were virtually guaranteed to win.
The phenomenon escalated into a frenzy, dividing opinions between fervent supporters and vocal detractors. Barrera-trained horses were no longer referred to by name or number in the betting world; a simple “Oscar” was sufficient. Spectators in the stands and at monitors would collectively chant “Oscar!” as the horses entered the stretch, a testament to the unwavering faith in his abilities. These horses displayed remarkable resilience, overcoming various race dynamics, including fast paces, lone speed strategies, and intense pressure. They possessed an almost supernatural ability to win, often demonstrating an extraordinary will to prevail.
There were instances where only extraordinary circumstances could thwart an Oscar-trained horse. Computer Carlos, for example, was so fast that his jockey, Rene Douglas, was nearly left behind as the horse bolted to victory. Even a fall wasn’t enough to stop Crème De La Fete, who literally stumbled to his knees, regained his footing, and rallied to win in one of the most astonishing races ever witnessed. Shifty Sheik, another Barrera claim, even gave the formidable Slew O’Gold a serious challenge in the 1984 Woodward Stakes. The success stories extended to the lineage of champions, with Silver Charm’s dam, Bonnie’s Poker, being an Oscar claim.
Despite the consistent success, “haters” often complained about the difficulty of betting races with Oscar Barrera entries, alleging improprieties. Authorities even raided his barn and placed him under surveillance, but nothing was ever found. The winning streak continued until it abruptly stopped, eventually fading into memory. Trainers attempting to replicate Barrera’s success by claiming his horses often failed, with Bob Lake being one notable example of a trainer who suffered significant losses.
The Barrera family, including Oscar’s brothers Luis and Guillermo, were highly respected horsemen. Oscar himself possessed a distinct Cuban accent and a straightforward communication style, often responding with “my horse got a shot” for horses he didn’t favor, and “I like this horse a lot” when he was confident. His most noticeable “tell” was his physical leaning towards the finish line as his horses ran, a sign that almost invariably preceded a win.
Reflecting on The Belmont Stakes, the “test of champions,” the Barrera brothers’ legacy intertwines with moments of racing greatness. Oscar’s elation mirrored that of his friend Jay after Alturas’ win. Furthermore, Luis Barrera, another brother, famously won a Belmont Stakes, thwarting a Triple Crown attempt. Oscar’s presence and evident joy in these celebrations underscored the strong familial bonds and the shared passion for the sport. The departed Barreras are remembered not only by their loved ones but by the racing community for their indelible contributions.
High 5
Victor Espinoza earns a high five for his exceptional ride on Hard Not to Like in The Gamely Stakes, a performance reminiscent of “Cool Hand Luke.” It’s opportune timing for Victor to hit a hot streak. A big high five also goes to Joe.
Low 5
NYRA receives a low five for capping attendance at The Belmont Stakes at 90,000. Given their 37-year lead time, a larger capacity should have been feasible. Hiring additional staff and implementing a robust plan would have allowed for greater attendance, especially when the goal is to expand the fan base. Rather than turning people away, NYRA should focus on increasing accessibility.
