The Monks of New Skete, with their well-intentioned efforts, have published books on dog training that, unfortunately, reveal a significant lack of comprehensive knowledge and proven training skills. While their ultimate goal—to foster well-behaved dogs integrated into family life—is commendable, their methods, particularly those outlined in “The Art of Raising a Puppy,” warrant a critical examination. This revised perspective aims to highlight concerns and suggest alternative, more effective approaches for dog owners.
Concerns with the Monks’ Training Philosophy
A central issue lies in the advice provided for addressing common puppy behaviors. For instance, the book suggests a “gentle scruff shake” and a verbal correction like “No, go to sleep” for a puppy whining on its first night away from its mother and littermates. This approach, arguably harsh for a distressed young animal, contradicts the goal of building a trusting relationship with a new companion. Furthermore, the housetraining method, involving covering the entire floor with newspaper, can present unnecessary challenges and prolong the learning process for puppies.
The “Completely Revised And Updated” edition continues to raise red flags, particularly in its guidance on feeding and discipline. Aggressive responses to possessiveness or growling, as described in the book, can escalate behavioral problems, especially during the sensitive developmental stages of a puppy’s life. The permanent impact of these early experiences cannot be overstated, and advice that could lead to aggression requires careful reconsideration. The book’s recommendation to introduce training collars, such as nylon choke collars and modified prong collars, after just a few months of using a flat or martingale collar is also problematic. These tools are often unnecessary for effective training and can inflict physical and psychological harm. The mention of remote or shock collars in their adult training program is particularly concerning, suggesting a reliance on aversive tools rather than positive reinforcement techniques. Many dogs exhibiting behaviors mistaken for “dominance” are, in fact, lacking self-control, discipline, or proper training. Assertive or confident dogs may require firm leadership, but this can be achieved through positive methods without resorting to harshness or specialized “training collars.” For a more nuanced understanding of canine behavior and leadership, resources from experienced trainers like Suzanne Clothier or John Rogerson offer valuable insights, emphasizing partnership over adversarial relationships.
Recommended Resources for Effective Dog Training
For owners seeking a more positive and effective approach to puppy raising and behavioral issues, several resources are highly recommended. John Rogerson’s “The Dog Vinci Code” offers a superior alternative, with Chapter 4, “Early Behavioural Development,” providing excellent guidance on housetraining and feeding. Chapters 42 and 44, “Understanding Aggression” and “Fear and Aggression,” respectively, offer a more constructive approach to dealing with growling and aggressive behaviors than what is presented in the Monks’ book.
Suzanne Clothier, a highly experienced professional in the animal world, also provides invaluable resources. Her book, “Bones Would Rain From The Sky,” particularly Chapter 17, delves into the application of compulsion or coercion when persuasion reaches its limits, always with a focus on ethical and effective methods. Clothier’s extensive experience in various canine disciplines, including obedience, agility, and breeding, underpins her authoritative and trustworthy approach to dog training.
Ultimately, the goal should be to cultivate a strong relationship with your dog, acting as a leader rather than an adversary. This approach fosters cooperation and a genuine partnership, resulting in a well-behaved and happy canine companion. The Monks of New Skete may do well to explore the methods of trainers who prioritize building trust and understanding, ensuring a more positive experience for both dogs and their owners.
