This review delves into a horse training simulation game, highlighting its core mechanics, areas for improvement, and potential for player engagement. While the game offers an immersive experience with features like training, showing, and breeding, several critical issues detract from its overall appeal and long-term playability. The primary concerns revolve around the in-game economy, the pacing of training, and the transparency of genetic factors.
In-Game Economy and Monetization
A significant drawback of the game is its flawed in-game economy, particularly the scarcity of the primary currency, coins. Players earn coins at an exceedingly slow rate, with daily login rewards offering a meager amount. The in-game shop, where most desirable items are located, exclusively uses coins for purchases. There are no alternative methods, such as in-game money earned from showing or training, to acquire these items. This forces players into a position where they must purchase coins with real money. The pricing structure is also perceived as overpriced, with the lowest tier offering only 50 coins for $3.99, which is insufficient to purchase even a few basic items from the shop. This imbalance in earning potential versus purchasing power creates a significant barrier to progression and enjoyment for players who are unwilling or unable to spend real money.
Training Pacing and Mechanics
The training system in the game suffers from excessively slow pacing. While players can train their horses through riding on trails, which provides a somewhat faster method for certain skill developments, there are crucial stats that cannot be effectively improved through this approach alone. This limitation necessitates relying on the game’s structured training system, which, due to its slow progression, can feel tedious and unrewarding. The lack of alternative or accelerated training methods for these specific stats hinders players from fully developing their horses to their potential.
Breeding System: A Work in Progress
The addition of a breeding system is a welcome feature, but it too is plagued by issues that limit its effectiveness and appeal. Firstly, the gestation period for mares is excessively long. During this time, the mare cannot be used for other game activities, effectively taking a valuable asset out of play for an extended period. Secondly, and perhaps more critically, the game fails to label genetic factors, particularly coat color and personality genes. While players with a background in equine genetics might understand common color genes, the game introduces unfamiliar ones without explanation. This lack of transparency makes it impossible for the average player to understand the potential outcomes of breeding or to strategically breed for specific traits. The absence of labeled personality genes further compounds this issue, leaving players breeding blindly into their foal’s genetic makeup.
Suggestions for Improvement
To elevate this game from a promising concept to a truly engaging experience, several key areas require attention. The in-game economy needs a significant overhaul. Introducing more ways to earn coins through gameplay, or offering alternative monetization options that do not feel predatory, would greatly improve player satisfaction. The training system could benefit from adjustments to pacing, perhaps by increasing the effectiveness of trail riding for all stats or by offering more engaging training mini-games.
The breeding system, while a positive addition, demands greater transparency. Clearly labeling all known genes, including color and personality traits, is essential. Providing an in-game encyclopedia or guide to these genes would empower players to make informed breeding decisions. Furthermore, reconsidering the gestation period or allowing mares to participate in limited activities during this time would improve its integration into the overall gameplay loop.
Finally, expanding the variety of in-game events beyond just jumping competitions would add much-needed diversity. Introducing other equestrian disciplines or challenges would cater to a broader range of player preferences. While breed expansion is a possibility for the future, addressing these fundamental gameplay mechanics should be the priority to ensure a robust and enjoyable foundation. This game has the potential to be a leading horse simulation, but it requires significant development to overcome its current limitations and fully satisfy its player base.
