Interdog aggression, often referred to as “sibling rivalry” between dogs, is a complex issue that can manifest in various ways beyond outright fights. Behaviors such as mounting, blocking, posturing, staring, and vocalization can all indicate underlying aggression. Understanding the root causes is the first step towards effective management and treatment. This guide explores the common reasons for interdog aggression, the owner’s role, and proven strategies for resolution.
Common Causes of Interdog Aggression
Aggression between dogs in the same household can stem from a multitude of factors, including dominance-related issues, territorial disputes, possessiveness over resources, or fear and anxiety. A specific form known as “alliance aggression” occurs when dogs only display aggression in their owner’s presence, behaving peacefully when alone. These dogs often compete for owner attention, especially when owners interact with both simultaneously. Hormone-driven aggression is also a possibility, particularly in intact males aggressive towards other males, females in heat, or mothers protecting their pups. Spaying or neutering can often alleviate this type of aggression.
Changes within the household environment can destabilize the social hierarchy and trigger aggression. Such changes may include the introduction of a new dog, a puppy reaching social maturity (around three years old), the declining health of an aging pet, or the loss of a canine or human family member. It’s crucial to recognize that a dog’s position within the social structure isn’t always fixed; it can be fluid and change depending on the situation. For example, one dog might have priority with toys, while another could be dominant when it comes to food. This dynamic nature makes identifying the “alpha dog” challenging.
Furthermore, certain predispositions can increase a dog’s likelihood of aggression. Poor socialization as puppies, traumatic social experiences (with humans or other dogs), or a lack of consistent training can all play a role. Studies indicate a significant overlap between aggression and other behavioral issues; up to 50% of aggressive dogs also suffer from separation anxiety, and 30% experience phobias or generalized anxiety. This suggests that aggression is often a coping mechanism for dogs feeling uncertain, anxious, or fearful. Approximately 20% of dogs exhibiting interdog aggression also direct aggression towards their owners, highlighting that owner conflict is frequently intertwined with the issue.
The Owner’s Role in Aggression
Owner behavior can inadvertently contribute to or exacerbate aggression. Interfering with normal social rituals, reinforcing aggressive behavior, frequent scolding or yelling (which increases a dog’s tension and arousal), inconsistent responses to a dog’s behavior, and a general lack of training and control can all escalate the problem.
When to Seek Professional Help
Before implementing any treatment, a veterinary examination is essential to rule out underlying physical conditions such as hormone disorders or painful ailments like arthritis, which can contribute to aggression. The overall safety of the home environment must also be assessed. If severe bites to humans or other dogs have occurred, if aggression triggers are unpredictable, or if the home situation makes treatment difficult, re-homing may be the most responsible course of action.
Aggression Treatment Strategies
Treating interdog aggression requires significant time, effort, and consistency, with noticeable improvement often taking weeks to months. However, with proper management, improvement is seen in approximately 96% of cases, with a median improvement rate of 69%. Treatment strategies typically involve:
Avoiding Aggressive Situations and Triggers: Identify and eliminate situations or resources that provoke aggressive responses. This includes managing competition for food, treats, toys, resting places, and owner attention. Dogs should be fed, given treats, played with, and allowed to greet owners separately. Denying free access to valuable resources and managing excitement levels during greetings or other stimulating events are crucial.
Implementing a “Nothing in Life Is Free” (NILIF) Program: This program establishes clear communication and consistent interactions. Dogs must earn everything they receive, including food, treats, toys, petting, and attention, by calmly following owner commands. This helps dogs learn impulse control and reduces pushy or attention-seeking behaviors. Consistent owner-initiated and owner-terminated interactions are key.
Showing Preference to One Dog: Consistently granting one dog priority access to resources like food, treats, preferred resting spots, toys, and entry/exit, as well as being the first to receive attention or have their leash put on, can reduce conflict by providing structure and predictability. If no improvement is seen after six weeks, switching the preference to the other dog may be beneficial.
Desensitization and Counter-Conditioning: This method involves gradually exposing dogs to each other in controlled, positive ways. Handlers maintain control using leashes, head halters, and possibly muzzles. Dogs are kept at a distance where they remain calm and are rewarded for obeying obedience commands. As sessions progress, the distance is slowly decreased, associating the other dog’s presence with positive experiences. Walking dogs together, with handlers between them initially, can also be a useful desensitization technique.
Medication: In some cases, veterinary-prescribed medication, such as fluoxetine (an SSRI), can help reduce anxiety and aggression. However, medication is most effective when used in conjunction with behavior modification techniques.
Additional Tips for Managing Aggression
- Exercise: Regular exercise can have a calming effect on dogs.
- Anti-Anxiety Products: Products like Adaptil (sprays, collars, diffusers) or Thundershirts may provide some relief for anxious dogs.
- Obedience Training: Reinforces good behavior and strengthens the owner-dog bond.
- Spaying/Neutering: Can help reduce hormone-driven aggression.
- Consistency: All household members must be on the same page regarding routines and interactions to avoid sending mixed messages to the dogs.
- Avoid Punishment: Punishment can escalate aggression or redirect it towards the owner.
Safety Measures
To enhance safety, consider using head collars with trailing leashes, allowing for easier separation if aggression occurs. Aversive spray deterrents can startle dogs apart without causing harm. Basket muzzles, which allow dogs to pant and drink, can be used if necessary, but traditional muzzles that close the mouth should be avoided. If fighting is severe, complete separation may be required until behavior modification can be effectively implemented.
For more in-depth guidance and to schedule an appointment, please contact us at (915) 592-6200.
