A woman looks out a window at a fire *Photo by Aaron Thomas.*
As pet owners, we often seek quick fixes for our pets’ undesirable behaviors. When a cat resorts to scratching furniture, our instinct is to deter them. However, as I learned a few years ago, employing deterrents like sticky tape or plastic barriers may not only be ineffective but could also exacerbate the problem. The key to managing destructive scratching lies not in stopping the behavior but in redirecting it to appropriate outlets, understanding that scratching is a natural and necessary cat behavior. This article explores why deterrents fail and offers effective, humane alternatives to protect your furniture and keep your feline companions happy.
What “Training” Tape Doesn’t Do
Products marketed as “training tape” for cats, such as double-sided sticky tape, are often misunderstood. While they might temporarily deter a cat from a specific spot, they don’t address the underlying reasons for scratching. Scratching serves essential functions for cats, including claw maintenance, stretching, and marking territory. When a cat is prevented from scratching in a preferred location, they experience frustration and stress. This unmet behavioral need can lead to redirected scratching on other furniture or manifest as different, unwanted behaviors. Ultimately, these deterrents do not train the cat; they merely displace the behavior and can create new problems.
It Can Easily Backfire
Attempting to block a cat from scratching furniture can lead to a phenomenon known as “spreading the destruction.” If a cat is denied access to their preferred scratching spot, they will seek an alternative, which might be another piece of furniture or a different part of the same item. This means the problem isn’t solved; it’s merely relocated. Furthermore, the frustration and stress caused by these deterrents can contribute to a range of behavioral issues beyond scratching. These can include increased anxiety, changes in litter box habits, aggression, or even compulsive behaviors. Addressing the root cause of scratching, rather than just the symptom, is crucial for a harmonious living environment.
The stress and frustration can lead to:
- Increased anxiety and fear
- Changes in litter box habits
- Aggression towards people or other pets
- Compulsive behaviors
- Destructive behaviors beyond scratching
- Changes in appetite or sleeping patterns
What To Do Instead
Instead of using deterrents, focus on understanding and redirecting your cat’s natural scratching instincts. Providing appropriate scratching alternatives is paramount. This includes offering a variety of scratching posts and surfaces with different textures, orientations (vertical, horizontal, angled), and stability. The placement of these scratchers is also critical; they should be located in areas where your cat already likes to scratch or frequent, such as near sleeping areas or main pathways. Enticing your cat to use these posts with catnip or pheromone sprays can also be effective. If scratching issues persist, consider addressing potential underlying stressors, illnesses, or pain that might be contributing to the behavior. Always ensure your cat has ample scratching options and that their behavioral needs are being met. You may need more than one scratching object, and likely more than one in each room to satisfy your cat’s needs.
Better Products To Protect Your Furniture
When redirection alone isn’t enough, or while you’re addressing underlying issues, various products can help protect your furniture without the negative consequences of deterrents.
Cover Them With A Scratcher
For furniture that is frequently targeted, such as the arms of sofas or chairs, consider using scratchers designed to drape over these areas. These provide a scratching surface while simultaneously protecting the furniture. Similarly, corner protectors, whether freestanding or adhesive, can safeguard vulnerable spots. Many of these options come in various colors and styles to match your decor and can be easily removed if needed.
Use An Adhesive Scratcher
If your cat scratches the back of chairs or other vertical surfaces, adhesive carpet scratchers are an excellent solution. These can adhere to a variety of materials and are available in numerous colors to blend in or add a decorative touch. While the adhesive is strong enough for scratching, it can typically be removed carefully without damaging the furniture. Always test in an inconspicuous area first.
Make It Art
For wall protection, consider decorative scratchers that double as artwork. Many are designed to look like stylized cat-themed art, adding both function and aesthetic appeal to your home.
Protecting Carpet
To protect carpets from scratching, flat sisal carpets can be placed in desired areas. These allow your cat to scratch while minimizing damage to your flooring. Alternatively, providing old carpet scraps or a rug your cat can shred is a sustainable and cost-effective option.
Alternatives To Double Sided Sticky Tapes To Stop Cat Scratching
The logic of allowing a cat to scratch in a location you wish to protect can seem counterintuitive. However, this method focuses on redirecting the natural behavior rather than suppressing it, which often proves more effective and less stressful for both the cat and owner. By working with your cat’s instincts and providing appropriate outlets, you foster a more positive relationship and a more peaceful home environment. This approach, focused on providing scratchers rather than deterrents, leads to happier cats and, consequently, happier humans.
Need help with your cat’s behavior?
Set Up a Consultation
