Choosing the right bag for dog walking can be a daunting task, with a plethora of options ranging from fanny packs to cross-body bags and backpacks. While the “perfect” pack might be elusive, this guide explores several excellent choices that balance functionality, comfort, and durability, helping you find the ideal companion for your canine adventures. This review focuses on packs that offer convenience and utility for dog walkers, considering factors like water resistance, pocket accessibility, and ease of wear.
1. Sling Bag: The Versatile Maleden Cross Body Bag
The Maleden cross-body bag emerges as a top pick due to its exceptional versatility and suitability for all weather conditions. Its ability to fit comfortably over a coat makes it a year-round option. During the extensive search for the ideal pack, this bag consistently proved its worth. While not a fan of traditional fanny packs, the Maleden offers similar accessibility benefits.
Key Features of the Maleden Cross Body Bag:
- Water-resistant material: Protects contents from light rain and splashes.
- Ample storage and pockets: Accommodates essentials like a phone, with numerous compartments for organization.
- Comfortable and compact design: Sits well on the body without being cumbersome.
- Lightweight construction: Reduces strain during long walks.
- Integrated D-ring: Useful for attaching keys or other accessories.
- Affordable price point: Offers great value for its features.
- Stylish color options: Available in various appealing colors.
- Capacity for a water bottle: Convenient for longer outings.
- Secure fit: When tightened, it stays in place and doesn’t shift excessively.
Potential Improvements:
- Not fully waterproof: May not withstand heavy downpours.
- Phone accessibility: While it fits, accessing the phone quickly can be a challenge.
- Lack of dedicated treat pocket: Requires improvising for treat storage.
Enhancements Made:
To optimize this bag for dog walking, several modifications were implemented:
- A quick-release keychain was attached to the hip pocket for easy access to deterrent spray.
- A grommet was installed on the bottom right side to create a convenient dog waste bag dispenser. Installing grommets is a simple DIY process, and they can be added to many items for added convenience.
- A dedicated poop bag holder was attached to the strap near the bottom.
- Treats were placed in a small baggie within the hip pocket for improved accessibility.
- Business cards and rack cards were stored in a Ziploc bag as a precaution against heavy rain.
2. Fanny Pack/Waist Pack: The Furry Buddy for Warmer Months
The Furry Buddy waist pack is the go-to option for warmer weather when shedding layers means losing pocket space. This pack is designed with hands-free walking in mind, although its primary benefit lies in its dedicated dog-walking features. Despite a few drawbacks, it remains a solid and frequently used choice.
Advantages of the Furry Buddy:
- Two heavy-duty D-rings: Secure attachment points for leashes.
- Reflective material: Enhances visibility during nighttime walks.
- Mostly waterproof: Offers good protection against the elements.
- Dedicated treat pouch: Keeps treats easily accessible.
- Durable construction: Built to withstand regular use.
- Easy access to contents: Thoughtful pocket placement aids in quick retrieval.
- Water bottle holder: Accommodates a water bottle for longer excursions.
Areas for Improvement:
- Phone fit: The designated phone spot is a tight squeeze for most smartphones.
- Price: It is on the higher end of the price spectrum.
- Bulkiness: Can be cumbersome and make bending over difficult.
- Sagging: Tends to sag when fully loaded.
- Dangling keys: The design can lead to keys dangling, which can be irritating.
- Bungee leashes: Integrated bungee leashes are not universally preferred.
Modifications for Better Use:
- A poop bag holder was attached to one of the D-rings for convenience.
- Wearing the pack backward proved to be a more comfortable and less obstructive method of use, especially when bending over.
3. Small Backpack: The OneTrail Mini Me 10 Liter Daypack
For those who prefer the structure and capacity of a backpack, the OneTrail Mini Me 10 Liter Daypack is a recommended option. Initially purchased for cycling, it seamlessly transitioned into a dog walking pack. It’s a great, smaller-sized pack, although its aesthetic may not appeal to everyone as much as the sling bag.
Strengths of the OneTrail Mini Me Daypack:
- Extremely lightweight: Does not add significant weight to your load.
- Convenient back pocket: Ideal for storing a phone.
- Affordable: A budget-friendly choice.
- Water bottle slots: Features external pockets for water bottles.
- Water-resistant: Offers protection against light moisture.
- Machine washable: Easy to clean after use.
- Sufficient space: Accommodates items like pens and business cards.
Potential Weaknesses:
- Flatness/Sagging: Can appear saggy if not filled adequately.
- Zipper durability: Zippers could be more robust.
- Chest buckle: The chest buckle can be somewhat annoying for some users.
Suggested Enhancements:
While no modifications were made to this pack for specific dog walking use, the following would be beneficial for frequent use:
- Installation of a grommet for dispensing waste bags.
- Attachment of a poop bag holder to the strap.
4. Shoulder Strap/Cross Body Bag: The DOOG Walkie Bag
While not personally owned, the DOOG Walkie Bag, based on a walker’s experience, presents an interesting option. The concept is appealing, but the mobility challenges associated with shoulder strap bags for dog walkers (frequent bending, greeting dogs, etc.) are a notable drawback. Shoulder bags can shift or fall forward, potentially posing a hazard. However, for those who prefer this style, the bag itself has some attractive features.
Appreciated Features of the DOOG Walkie Bag:
- Aesthetic appeal: Available in cute and fun colors.
- Integrated poo bag dispenser: A convenient built-in feature.
- Phone compatibility: Designed to fit a standard phone.
- Partially waterproof: Offers some protection against moisture.
- Water bottle spot: Includes a dedicated space for a water bottle.
- Space for materials: Can hold branded items or business cards.
Areas Lacking:
- Poo Bag Dispenser design: Optimized for DOOG brand bags, making other brands a tight fit.
- Price: Considered expensive by some.
- Accessibility: The flap closure can hinder quick access to contents.
Adaptations for Improved Functionality:
- Waist pack conversion: Using carabiners to attach the bag to a belt effectively transforms it into a waist pack.
- Cross-body stability: Wearing it across the body can offer greater stability.
5. Treat Pouches: The Paw Lisfestyles Pouch
Treat pouches are arguably the most commonly used and advertised bags for dog training and walking. The Paw Lisfestyles Pouch was a favorite for initial dog walking endeavors and is now best suited for training sessions in the backyard or focused command work. Its storage capacity is limited for carrying a wider range of items needed for longer walks.
Pros of the Paw Lisfestyles Pouch:
- Easy treat access: Designed for quick treat retrieval.
- Integrated poo bag dispenser: A handy feature for waste disposal.
- Compact size: Not overly large or cumbersome.
- Easy to clean: Simple maintenance.
- Dual D-rings: Offers multiple attachment points.
- Affordable: A cost-effective option.
- Front mesh pocket: Suitable for holding a phone.
- Versatile wear options: Can be worn in three different ways.
Limitations:
- Limited storage: Insufficient space for extensive gear.
- Poo bag dispenser placement: Not ideally positioned for some users.
- Weight distribution: Can become heavy when loaded with keys, spray, treats, and a phone.
- Material durability: Could be more robust for heavy use.
Alternative for Treat-Focused Needs:
For those seeking a small pouch dedicated solely to treats, the Pet Safe Treat Pouch is a recommended alternative.
Bonus: Travel Bag – The Modoker Dog Travel Bag
While not intended for daily walks, the Modoker Dog Travel Bag is an essential for any traveling pet owner. It simplifies packing by conveniently holding food, dishwasher-safe bowls, and easily fitting onto luggage. The availability of various attractive colors is an added bonus.
The Indispensable Poop Bag Holder
A crucial accessory for any dog walker is a reliable poop bag holder. The specific model mentioned and pictured throughout this guide is highly recommended for its practicality and ease of use.
Happy Walking!
