Best Small Dog Toys for Chewers: A Guide to Safe & Durable Play

Lady holding her small dog while picking the safest chew toys

There’s nothing quite as heartwarming as watching your small dog gleefully pounce on a favorite toy, tail wagging with unbridled joy. These moments of play are more than just fun; they are a vital part of keeping our beloved small companions happy, healthy, and thoroughly entertained, especially for those with a strong urge to chew. Finding the Best Small Dog Toys For Chewers can be a challenge, as these tiny titans require toys that are both appropriately sized and incredibly durable. In a previous discussion, we highlighted the importance of avoiding toxic toys that could harm our precious pups. Building on that, this guide will provide valuable insights into selecting safe and non-toxic toys specifically tailored for small breed chewers, ensuring their playtime is both safe and satisfying.

Identifying Safe Chew Toys for Your Small Dog

Choosing the right toys for your small dog, particularly a strong chewer, goes beyond mere entertainment—it’s about their safety. Looks can be deceiving; a toy might seem fun but could pose a risk if not suitable for their chewing habits and size. When on the hunt for the best small dog toys for chewers, keep these crucial factors in mind to identify truly safe options.

Toy Material Matters

The foundation of a safe dog toy lies in its material. Unlike human products, dog toys are not regulated by the FDA, with oversight by the Consumer Product Safety Commission only pertaining to risks to humans. Many toys, especially certain plastics, can contain hazardous chemicals that may be life-threatening to dogs. It’s essential to be vigilant about ingredients. Prioritize toys made from Grade A or natural rubber, or those crafted from natural fibers such as cotton, wool, or hemp. These materials offer durability without compromising your small dog’s health. For more detailed information on avoiding harmful substances, you might find our article on best dog toys for dogs that chew helpful.

Manufacturing Standards and Brand Reputation

Always opt for toys from reputable manufacturers who are transparent about their production processes and avoid toxic coatings, chemicals, or harmful dyes. Checking recall lists, such as the FDA’s animal/veterinary recalls, can help identify brands with potential manufacturing issues. Trustworthy brands often have a solid reputation within the pet industry and come recommended by veterinarians and animal care experts. They are committed to producing high-quality, safe products for your pets.

Lady holding her small dog while picking the safest chew toysLady holding her small dog while picking the safest chew toys

Appropriate Size is Crucial for Small Chewers

For a toy to be genuinely safe for a small dog, its size is paramount. Toys that are too small present a significant choking hazard, as eager chewers might attempt to swallow them whole or get them lodged in their mouths. For small dogs, choose toys that they can comfortably hold and carry in their mouths without struggling, but are too large to be ingested. Avoid toys with small, detachable parts like strings, beads, bells, or plastic eyes, which can easily come loose and be swallowed. When selecting the best small dog toys for chewers, always prioritize items that are specifically designed for their size to prevent accidental choking or obstruction. If your small dog is still a puppy, consider exploring best hard chew toys for puppies for age-appropriate options.

Durability for the Determined Chewer

Small dogs, despite their size, can be incredibly determined chewers. To prevent them from breaking toys into small, swallowable pieces, or cutting themselves on sharp edges, the safest chew toys are crafted from durable materials. Rubber and silicone are excellent choices for safe, non-toxic dog toys. These materials offer the necessary durability while remaining pliable enough to protect your pet’s teeth from damage. A simple “thumbnail test” can help assess a toy’s durability: if your thumbnail can make a slight indent, it’s generally safe for chewing. If your thumbnail bends, the toy might be too hard and risk breaking teeth. This test is particularly useful when searching for the best small dog toys for chewers to ensure they can withstand rigorous gnawing without splintering or causing dental harm. For puppies, it’s essential to consider teething toys for large breed puppies if your small breed has a powerful bite, as the principles of durability remain similar.

Common Dog Toy Types and Safety Tips for Small Chewers

Whether your small dog loves a spirited game of fetch, a cuddly plush toy, or a challenging puzzle, there are safe and fun options to keep them happily engaged. Understanding your small dog’s unique play style, needs, and preferences is key to selecting toys that are not only fun but also promote their health and safety.

  • Chew Toys: These are perfect for high-energy small dogs who need an outlet for their chewing instincts. Safe and healthy chew toys for small breeds should be made from sturdy materials like rubber, silicone, or nylon, specifically designed to endure a small dog’s strong jaw. They not only relieve stress but also contribute to dental hygiene.
  • Interactive and Puzzle Toys: Excellent for both mental and physical stimulation, these toys are great for small dogs. Options include treat-dispensing toys or small puzzle toys that challenge their minds and keep them entertained.
  • Fetch and Tug Toys: Ideal for active playtime and ensuring your small dog gets ample exercise. Look for small, soft balls, flexible flying discs, or small knots of thick rope that are easy for them to grip and carry. If you’re wondering about suitable toys for very young small chewers, check out best toys for 8 week old puppy for guidance.

It’s also essential to regularly clean, replace, and rotate your small dog’s toys. Cleaning toys helps reduce bacterial spread; opt for washable materials. Replacing damaged toys is crucial to prevent injuries and choking hazards. Rotating toys maintains interest and extends their lifespan, making sure your small dog always has engaging and safe options.

Small dog playing with a small, durable chew toySmall dog playing with a small, durable chew toy

Recommended Safe Chew Toys for Small Dogs

As dedicated pet owners, we understand the importance of choosing toys that bring joy while ensuring the well-being of our furry companions. Here are a few recommended options known for prioritizing both fun and safety, making them strong contenders for the best small dog toys for chewers.

  • Kong®-type products: A dog toy best-seller since the 1970s, Kong offers a wide variety of strong rubber toys in various sizes, including options perfect for small dogs. These are widely recommended by veterinarians for their durability and design that allows for treat stuffing.
  • West Paw Zogoflex® toys: West Paw’s proprietary Zogoflex® material is completely recyclable, free from latex, BPA, and phthalates. Their toys are durable, specifically some smaller sizes, and dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning, making them excellent choices for aggressive small chewers.
  • Bully Max Indestructible Ball: This non-toxic, industrial-strength ball is a great, safe, and durable alternative for small dogs who love to chew. Made from eco-friendly natural rubber, it’s designed to prevent pieces from breaking off and can be easily cleaned in the dishwasher.
  • Goughnuts rings or sticks: Crafted from 100% natural rubber, Goughnuts toys include a “Chew Toy Safety Indicator”—a colored mechanism that signals when the toy should be replaced. They offer smaller sizes suitable for little mouths, providing peace of mind for owners of avid chewers.
  • Tuffy Toys: While plush, Tuffy Toys are highly durable, made from multiple bonded layers of FDA-approved, non-toxic, food-grade materials. They are a good option for small dogs that enjoy a soft toy to cuddle but also have a tendency to chew, offering a safer and longer-lasting alternative to many other plush toys. If you have a small dog but a big chewer, you might also consider products listed in cute dog toys for big dogs, looking for their smaller, tougher variants.

Always supervise your small dog during playtime and promptly remove any toys that show signs of fraying or breakage, as damaged toys can become dangerous. If you notice any bleeding from your dog’s mouth or gums during play, switch to a gentler option immediately. When in doubt about a specific toy or product, don’t hesitate to consult your veterinarian for expert advice.


Finding the best small dog toys for chewers is an investment in your pet’s long-term health and happiness. By understanding the importance of material, manufacturing standards, appropriate sizing, and durability, you can make informed choices that ensure safe and engaging playtime. Prioritizing non-toxic and robust toys helps prevent injuries, promotes dental health, and provides an essential outlet for your small dog’s natural chewing instincts. Remember that regular inspection and replacement of toys are key components of responsible pet ownership. Choose wisely, and enjoy many happy moments with your cherished canine companion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *