White Nero playing with durable dog toys at shelter

Tired of buying indestructible dog toys that last only minutes? As dog owners and shelter volunteers at Benafim Dog Shelter, we’ve felt that frustration too. Our powerful chewers—like Pitt bull Nero, Cane Corso cross Black Nero, and playful Maya—destroy average toys in no time. We’ve tested hundreds, spending £76.31 on five popular indestructible dog toys to find what’s truly tough. For aggressive chewers, check out our guide to the best dog toy for power chewers.

These toys faced a week of intense chewing, burying, fetching, and water play by our shelter pack: Nero, Max, Maya, Black Nero, Jean, Pebbles, and more. No diplomacy here—just honest dog-approved verdicts on durability, fun, and dental benefits.

Five indestructible dog toys tested by shelter dogs

Nylabone Extreme Tough Dog Chew Toy Review

Nylabone Extreme Tough Dog Chew Toy in Bison flavor

We paid £19.16 for this XXL Bison-flavored Nylabone, designed for dogs over 23kg and extreme chewers. Nero, our 9-year-old Pitt bull with unmatched smarts and jaws, chomped for hours without denting it. Its lightweight 485g build (30.48 x 13.97 x 5.08 cm) lets dogs carry it easily, while the curved shape aids paw-gripping for satisfying chews.

Maya, a 3-year-old rescue new to toys, instantly loved it—chewing vigorously and running with it, sparking chases from Max. Black Nero, infamous for snapping tree trunks and bending fences when anxious, couldn’t scratch it despite relentless effort.

Nero chewing the durable Bison Nylabone

Easy to clean (no flavor loss or mess), it features raised nubs for teeth cleaning. Non-toxic nylon is safe for power chewers.

Maya and Max playing tug with NylaboneBlack Nero failing to destroy Nylabone after hours

Dog Gallery: Chewing Action

Komo gnawing on NylaboneNora enjoying the tough chewWhite Nero gripping Nylabone firmly

Verdict: Paws-up from every shelter dog. Ideal for bored, heavy chewers needing durable, flavored dental toys. Check price on Amazon

Kong Rewards Ball Review

Kong Rewards Ball for treat-dispensing play

At £9.99 (12.7 x 12.7 x 12.07 cm, 417g), this is for 16kg+ dogs. Initial enthusiasm was mild, but the bouncy rubber won them over. Treat insertion is simple; dispensing requires minimal effort.

Jean obsessed, burying it after hours of chewing the squidgy side—denying Komo access. From tiny Star to giant Jambo, no tooth marks or leftover treats appeared.

Jean burying the chewed Kong Rewards Ball

For pups with destructive habits, pair it with indestructible chew toys for large dogs.

Dog Gallery: Play and Chew Tests

Nora batting Kong Rewards BallJean biting the treat ballBaldo tossing Kong BallStar interacting with durable toyJambo chewing the bouncy ball

Verdict: Combines play, bounce, and treats perfectly. Tough against chewing—great indestructible dog toy for interactive fun. Check price on Amazon

CyunCmay Indestructible XL Bone Review

CyunCmay XL Indestructible Dog Bone

£14.99 for this 32.9 x 12.2 x 3.8 cm, 330g TPR bone (non-toxic, plaque-fighting). Excitement peaked on unboxing, with tug-of-war via handles and lake fetches.

But Black Nero split it in 30 minutes—soft rubber couldn’t handle his power.

Black Nero jumping with CyunCmay boneBroken CyunCmay bone with teeth marksPebbles relaxing with XL bone

Dog Gallery: Short-Lived Fun

Jean tugging orange boneNora chewing CyunCmay boneKilo playing fetchJean with damaged bonePebbles guarding bonePebbles lying with toyWhite Nero fetching bone

Verdict: Fun for fetch, not chewing. Not truly indestructible for power chewers. Check price on Amazon

Hetoo Indestructible Squeaky Dental Toy Review

Hetoo squeaky dental care dog toy

£16.32 natural rubber toy (12.7 x 12.7 x 12.07 cm, 417g) for dental health. Squeak and odd shape baffled most; Maya hid initially but inspected later. Peanut butter helped briefly.

Maya inspecting Hetoo toy

Dog Gallery: Minimal Interest

Black Nero with Hetoo boneMaya near squeaky toy

Verdict: Short-lived appeal, annoying squeak. Not engaging for indestructible dog toys seekers. Check price on Amazon

Kong Wobbler Treat Dispenser Review

Kong Wobbler interactive treat toy

£15.85 plastic polymer wobbler (13 x 19 cm diameter, 485g, up to 250g treats) for 12kg+ dogs. Its size and wobble confused at first on rough surfaces, but smooth floors and small treats unlocked fun.

Pebbles persisted smartly.

Pebbles nudging Kong Wobbler

For aggressive pups, see best puppy chew toys for aggressive chewers.

Dog Gallery: Wobble Challenges

Komo puzzled by WobblerKilo trying to solve toyClimber batting WobblerPebbles with treat dispenser

Verdict: Durable once mastered—indestructible and slows eating. Check price on Amazon

Try best chew toys for husky puppies or best dog chew bones for puppies for similar needs.

Final Verdict on Indestructible Dog Toys

Our shelter pros crown Nylabone for chewers, Kong Rewards Ball for players, and Kong Wobbler for thinkers. Skip CyunCmay and Hetoo for true power chewers. Real tests prove durability matters—choose wisely to keep tails wagging. Consult vets for dental needs, and share your chewer stories below!